11 Types Of Edible Mushrooms Identification In Backyard

Ever seen mushrooms on a stroll in the backyard? You might think nothing of it, but those mushrooms can be poisonous! Learn how to identify edible mushrooms!

Searching for wild mushrooms in your own backyard can be a thrilling and satisfying adventure. However, it’s important to be aware of which mushrooms are safe to consume and which ones are not.

Although there are numerous types of edible mushrooms in the wild, distinguishing them from their toxic counterparts can be a daunting task.

Identifying mushrooms correctly is vital to prevent accidental ingestion of poisonous ones.

This blog aims to offer guidance on Edible Mushrooms Identification in your backyard.

Edible Mushrooms Identification in Your Backyard

Identifying edible mushrooms in your backyard is very important, especially if you are new to the vegetation world.

Whether growing mushrooms in bottles, jars, or hydroponically, Edible mushrooms have some common characteristics that you can familiarize yourself with to save yourself trouble the next time you find mushrooms on your walking trail.

  1. One obvious sign to look for in edible mushrooms is pores or gills on the underside of the mushroom cap.
  2. The other obvious sign is color. Edible mushrooms come in white, cream colors, and even dark brown or black.
  3. Of course, you cannot solely rely on color, as edible mushrooms share the same color pallet as poisonous mushrooms.
  4. The smell of the mushroom can also help you identify edible mushrooms from poisonous ones. Some mushrooms have a sweet, fruity smell, while others smell like almonds.
  5. The shape and texture of the mushroom can also indicate if it is edible or not. Edible mushroom caps feel firm and fleshy to the touch.

Safety Considerations Before Identifying Edible Mushrooms

It’s important to consider safety before identifying edible mushrooms in your backyard.

Identifying mushrooms can be tricky, and some poisonous species resemble edible ones. When foraging for mushrooms, it’s essential to know what you’re looking for.

So, before heading out into the woods, familiarize yourself with common edibles and their toxic look-alikes.

  • Avoid picking mushrooms near highways or other sources of pollution, as they may have absorbed harmful chemicals.
  • Using proper tools like gloves and knives while harvesting any wild mushroom is crucial.
  • Never pull up a mushroom by its stem or twist off its cap because this damages the fungus and surrounding mycelium.

If you’re not 100% sure about any mushroom species’ or whether it’s safe to eat or not, don’t take risks!

Differentiate between edible and poisonous mushroom

The following is a table that provides a simple comparison of key characteristics that can assist in distinguishing between edible and dangerous mushrooms; however, keep in mind that there are always exceptions to every rule.

Edible Vs poisonous mushroom
FeatureEdible MushroomsPoisonous Mushrooms
CapMay have various shapes and colors, including brown, white, cream, yellow.May also have a variety of shapes and colors, some poisonous mushrooms can strongly resemble edible ones.
Gills, Pores, or SpinesMost edible mushrooms have free gills (not attached to the stem) or pores, but there are exceptions.Many poisonous mushrooms have attached gills, but there are also exceptions. Mushrooms with white gills can often be poisonous.
Spore Print ColorCan be a variety of colors, depending on the species.Can also vary widely in color. A spore print is an important identification feature but alone is not enough to determine edibility.
Ring or VeilSome edible mushrooms have a ring, some don’t.Many poisonous mushrooms, especially deadly Amanita species, have a prominent ring and a bulbous base.
StemCan be central, off-center, or absent. The base might be bulbous, equal, or tapering.Often have a pleasant or “mushroomy” smell, but the odor can vary and is not a reliable indicator of edibility.
HabitatVarious habitats, depending on the species. Many grow in woods, on lawns, and on compost.Various habitats, similar to edible mushrooms. Some dangerous species are common in urban areas.
Bruising or DiscolorationSome edible species discolor when cut or bruised, but this is not a definitive feature of edibility.Some poisonous mushrooms discolor when bruised, but again, not all do. For example, some poisonous Boletus species turn blue when cut.
OdorOften have a pleasant or “mushroomy” smell, but odor can vary and is not a reliable indicator of edibility.Some poisonous mushrooms have a foul, unpleasant, or unusual smell, but some also smell quite good.

Again, this is a very basic overview so please consult with an expert or a detailed field guide before consuming any wild mushrooms.

See also  Growing Squash in Containers: 6 Caring + How-to Tips

Check below Portable Mushroom Growing Tent, to buy now

Litytlen Portable Mushroom Growing Tent-Spore Fungus Fume Hood Propagation Stations.

11 Common Edible Backyard Mushrooms

If you’re new to this mushroom scavenger hunt, it’s important to start with those that are easy to identify and have no poisonous look-alike.

Here are some mushrooms that are safe to eat:

1. Oyster Mushrooms

Oyster mushrooms have a delicate, sweet flavor with a velvety texture, making them perfect for salads, soups, or sauteed dishes.

These mushrooms typically grow in clusters on dead trees or fallen logs during the summer and fall months.

Back to the Roots Organic Mushroom Grow Kit - Oyster and Pink Mushroom 2-Pack Variety - Indoor Non-GMO Growing Kit - Produces 3-4 Servings and Grows in 10 Days

They can be identified by their unique fan-shaped caps ranging from white to greyish-brown.

  • When picking oyster mushrooms, choosing ones with firm caps and no signs of decay or insect damage is important.
  • Avoid any mushroom with yellow gills as they may indicate poisonous look-alike species.
  • Oyster mushrooms are easy to prepare – simply rinse them thoroughly under running water and pat dry before slicing them into bite-sized pieces.
  • In addition to being delicious, oyster mushrooms are also packed with nutrients such as protein, potassium, and vitamin D.

So next time you spot these tasty fungi growing in your backyard, don’t hesitate to pick some for a flavorful meal!

2. Puffball Mushrooms

Puffball mushrooms also called Calvatia gigantea, are unique and popular edible mushrooms that grow in many backyards.

These mushrooms can reach up to 10” in diameter, making them one of the largest kinds of edible backyard mushrooms.

One of the most distinguishing features of puffball mushrooms is their shape. They have a very round, ball-like appearance that makes them easy to recognize.

Unlike other types of mushrooms, they do not have gills or pores on the underside.

See also  Why tomato plant leaves turning yellow: Reasons + Fixes

Puffball mushrooms are also known for their texture and taste. When cooked properly, they have a soft, spongy texture.

However, it’s important to note that not all puffball mushrooms are safe to eat. Some species look similar but are poisonous and can cause serious health problems if ingested.

Just be sure to be cautious and use proper identification methods before eating any kind of wild mushroom!

3. Black Trumpet Mushrooms

Black Trumpet mushrooms are a delicacy that can be found in many backyards across the United States.

These mushrooms have a unique funnel shape and an earthy flavor that pairs well with many dishes. They grow during the late summer and early fall months.

Identifying black trumpet mushrooms is relatively easy due to their distinct shape and coloring.

They are typically dark brown or black on the outer surface but have a light-colored interior that ranges from gray to white.

Black trumpets grow in clusters on dead hardwood trees, so watch them while exploring your backyard.

  • When harvesting black trumpet mushrooms, cutting them off at ground level rather than pulling them out of the ground is important.
  • This ensures that any spores left behind will continue to grow more mushrooms in the future.
  • Preparing black trumpets is simple – they can be sauteed with butter and garlic or added as a topping for pizzas or pasta. Due to their delicate texture, it’s best not to overcook them.
  • While these mushrooms are generally safe to eat, it’s important to properly identify them before consuming them as there are poisonous look-alikes, such as jack-o’-lanterns which resemble Black Trumpet Mushrooms.

4. Chanterelles

Chanterelles are one of the most popular edible mushrooms that can easily be found in your backyard.

Roland Foods Canned Chanterelle Mushrooms, Specialty Canned Food, 7.9-Ounce Can

They have a distinct trumpet shape with a golden yellow or orange color, making them easy to identify. Chanterelles have a delicate and nutty flavor that pairs well with many dishes.

These mushrooms grow in clusters near trees such as oak, fir, or hemlock. They prefer moist soil and can often be found after rain showers during the summer months.

It’s important to note that chanterelles should not be confused with jack-o-lantern mushrooms, which are poisonous.

  • To harvest chanterelles, you should use a sharp knife to gently cut them at the base of their stem instead of pulling them out by hand.
  • This will prevent any damage to the underground mycelium network and ensure future growth for years to come.
  • When preparing chanterelles, it’s best to clean them thoroughly before cooking.
  • You can use a brush or damp cloth to remove any dirt or debris from their caps and stems without soaking them in water, as they absorb moisture quickly.

5. Morel mushrooms

Morel mushrooms, also known as Morchella, are most commonly seen growing in wooded areas; however, they can also be discovered in backyards, particularly in areas that are shaded by ash, old apple, and elm trees.

Vigorous Mountains Wild Dried Morel Mushrooms 1 Ounce and VIGOROUS MOUNTAINS Dried Porcini Mushrooms 3 Ounce

6. Shaggy Mane

The Shaggy Mane, also known as Coprinus comatus, is a plant that is frequently discovered growing on lawns and along gravel roads.

7. Wine Cap Mushroom

The Wine Cap Mushroom, scientifically known as Stropharia rugosoannulata, is also known as “King Stropharia” or “Garden Giant,” and it is frequently discovered in wood chips and garden beds.

8. Inky Caps

Inky Caps are a species of the genus Coprinoid and can be found growing in lawns and on wood chips. They should be consumed shortly after being picked or else they will “autodigest” and become an inky mess.

See also  8 Spinach Companion Plants: Benefits + Best To Worst Plants

9. Laetiporus sulphureus

The Chicken of the Woods, or Laetiporus sulphureus, is a fungus that can be found growing on both living and dead trees. It is most commonly found in yards that have trees.

10. Grifola frondosa

These mushrooms, also known as maitake or hen of the woods (Grifola frondosa), frequently colonise the ground around the bases of trees, particularly oaks.

11. fairy ring mushrooms

These mushrooms, which are scientifically known as Marasmius oreades, grow in lawns in a circular pattern that is referred to as a “fairy ring.”

Mushroom Look alike: How to Avoid Poisonous Mushrooms

Identifying edible mushrooms can be a fun and rewarding activity, but knowing how to avoid poisonous mushrooms is important.

Some poisonous varieties look very similar to their edible counterparts, which can make identification difficult for beginners.

  • One common example is the false morel, which looks similar in appearance to the highly prized morel mushroom.
  • However, false morels contain a toxin called gyromitrin that can cause serious health problems if ingested.
  • Another dangerous look-alike is the death cap mushroom. This deadly fungus closely resembles several edible species of mushroom and contains anatoxins that target the liver and kidneys.
  • To avoid these potentially lethal mistakes, it’s essential that you do your research before picking any wild mushrooms from your backyard or nearby woods.
  • Familiarize yourself with all potential toxic varieties found in your area and learn how they differ from their safe counterparts.

Remember always to take caution when identifying mushrooms, as even experienced hunters have accidentally picked poisonous ones thinking they’re safe!

7 Most deadliest mushrooms

There are numerous types of poisonous mushrooms, but the seven listed below are considered to be among the most dangerous because of the severity of their toxicity and/or the prevalence of their distribution:

1. Death Cap

The Death Cap (Amanita phalloides) is a type of poisonous fungus that is responsible for the majority of fatal mushroom poisonings around the world.

It contains multiple toxic chemicals that are capable of causing serious damage to the liver and kidneys.

2. Destroying Angels

Destroying Angels (Amanita virosa, A. bisporigera, A. verna, A. ocreata):

These fungi live up to their name, as they are exceedingly hazardous to one’s health. They are poisonous in exactly the same way as the death cap is.

3. Autumn Skullcap

The Autumn Skullcap, also known as Galerina marginata, is a little brown fungus that carries the same lethal amatoxins as other mushrooms with similar names, including the death cap and destroying angels.

4. Cortinarius orellanus

Both the Fool’s Webcap (Cortinarius orellanus) and the Deadly Webcap (Cortinarius rubellus) are species of the genus Cortinarius.

Both species are known to harbour a poison known as orellanine, which is capable of wreaking havoc on the kidneys and the liver.

5. Lepiota brunneoincarnata

Lepiota brunneoincarnata, also known as the Deadly Dapperling: A harmless-looking mushroom that can be toxic because of the presence of amatoxins.

Because it is so easy to confuse it with other species, it poses a unique threat to human health.

6. Podostroma Cornu-damae

Podostroma Cornu-damae is an extremely rare fungus that is native to Asia. It produces severe toxins that can lead to the failure of several organs as well as changes in the skin and hair.

7. False Morel

False Morel (Gyromitra esculenta): Some people are able to consume them after thorough cooking without obvious harm; but, if consumed raw or cooked improperly, they can be quite toxic, and the reactions that they cause can be unpredictable.

How to Identify Edible Mushrooms FAQs

Q: What Are Some Safety Considerations To Keep In Mind Before Consuming Wild Mushrooms?

Before consuming wild mushrooms, educating yourself on poisonous species and identifying any mushrooms you plan to eat positively is essential.

Always collect mushrooms from a safe, toxic-free area and avoid consuming any mushrooms with a bitter taste, a pungent odor, or any that appear rotting.

Q: What Common Look-Alike Mushrooms Should Be Avoided When Foraging For Edible Mushrooms In Your Backyard?

Some common look-alike mushrooms that should be avoided when foraging for edible mushrooms in your backyard include the deadly Galerina and the poisonous False Morel.

Both mushrooms can be easily mistaken for edible species, so it is crucial to know the differences between them before consuming any wild mushrooms.


Finding and picking mushrooms you can eat in your backyard can be a fun and tasty experience.

Before eating any wild mushrooms, it’s important to know a lot about what they look like and how to keep yourself safe.

Always be sure you know what kind of mushrooms you want to eat, and only eat mushrooms that you are sure are safe to eat.

With the right knowledge and care, you can get a lot out of picking and cooking your own edible mushrooms.